Following the leadership change in the Liberal Party, new PM Malcolm Turnbull has also changed the look of cabinet.
Sometimes, it can be too easy to understate the importance of a leader in shaping the direction a party moves in when trying to compensate for the fact that too much attention is paid to the leader in other matters by the media (and, by extension, the public). Yet here we see how important the leader is in pushing their party in one direction or another. Abbott, a true conservative with a conservative cabinet, has been replaced by Turnbull, a true liberal with a liberal cabinet.
In the media, this has generally been reported using the misnomer of Turnbull's cabinet having 'moderates', a false political terms that equates liberalism with a middle ground.
Those who have entered the cabinet are, for the most part, renowned more for their economic liberalism than anything else. These types tend to stay quieter on which way they lean socially, though that says plenty about them in and of itself. Scott Morrison is one of the few promoted who is openly conservative, but he's simply moving up the ranks within cabinet rather than coming in from the outer ministry or the backbenches.
Compare also those entering (such as Kelly O'Dwyer, Michaelia Cash and Josh Frydenberg) to those exiting (such as Tony Abbott, Kevin Andrews and Eric Abetz). The broad theme is clear: liberalism is good, conservatism is bad. The unique way the Liberal Party was brought about (as a merger of anti-socialist causes) has meant there has always been a delicate balancing act going on between the liberals and the conservatives. Malcolm Turnbull has made his intentions clear with his cabinet, although the given the party room is fairly equally split between the two he is unlikely to go for the jugular on issues conservatives are likely to revolt over (mostly being issues of society). Instead, he will probably focus on further liberalising the economy.
Case in point: lowering weekend penalty rates. This issue was first brought up by the Productivity Commission in August, but such an issue seemed to be the kind of thing Abbott's government would rather leave alone, or at least to those who cared more about it (which essentially consisted of economic liberals). Now, with Turnbull in charge, penalty rates are now at the forefront of the agenda. Not only has the Prime Minister said that it would be brought before cabinet, but two of the aforementioned new ministers (Cash and Frydenberg) have spoken out in favour of it.
From now until the election, we should expect this kind of policy focus. The economy is relatively safe ground, in that as long as it is doing well enough, the government can reap the electoral benefits. Social policy is far more likely to be contested, particularly amongst Liberal voters, and is therefore best avoided until the next term. Whether the people buy the message of economic reform, though, is another matter.
Showing posts with label australian politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label australian politics. Show all posts
Saturday, 3 October 2015
Monday, 14 September 2015
'We have lost 30 Newspolls in a row'
Of all the things that have been and will be said about the latest in our cycle of prime ministerial changes, it is this quote by Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull (get used to that) that defines what this is all about.
Read it again.
'We have lost 30 Newspolls in a row.'
If you need to know how politicians treat their position, there it is. It is not about serving in office, as decided by the people; it is about 'winning power', about being in front at all times, regardless of what that means for the nation in the long term. It is about style over substance, even if that requires using the idea of substance as your style, as Turnbull seems eager to do.
There is plenty more that can be said about this event. As I type, the Prime Minister has claimed that he is 'humbled' by his party's choice. This is hardly a shining example of humility. But, also occurring as I type, Turnbull is making clear that he desires a traditional Cabinet style of government. If he manages to balance the modern stylism with traditional Cabinet government, he will have done well.
But it is curious to claim that this was not about leadership style tonight, but instead about internal culture, after claiming only hours ago that the Australian people had pronounced judgement on the government...which is primarily, today, a matter of style.
'We have lost 30 Newspolls in a row.'
I suspect Turnbull will be hoping this quote disappears into the ether. He must demonstrate that his government is not purely guided by the polls, if he is truly about 'the future'.
Read it again.
'We have lost 30 Newspolls in a row.'
If you need to know how politicians treat their position, there it is. It is not about serving in office, as decided by the people; it is about 'winning power', about being in front at all times, regardless of what that means for the nation in the long term. It is about style over substance, even if that requires using the idea of substance as your style, as Turnbull seems eager to do.
There is plenty more that can be said about this event. As I type, the Prime Minister has claimed that he is 'humbled' by his party's choice. This is hardly a shining example of humility. But, also occurring as I type, Turnbull is making clear that he desires a traditional Cabinet style of government. If he manages to balance the modern stylism with traditional Cabinet government, he will have done well.
But it is curious to claim that this was not about leadership style tonight, but instead about internal culture, after claiming only hours ago that the Australian people had pronounced judgement on the government...which is primarily, today, a matter of style.
'We have lost 30 Newspolls in a row.'
I suspect Turnbull will be hoping this quote disappears into the ether. He must demonstrate that his government is not purely guided by the polls, if he is truly about 'the future'.
Saturday, 29 August 2015
Joe Hockey's week of distractions
Peter FitzSimons, rugby union international, author and bandana wearer, spoke at the National Press Club this week. The topic? The rebirth of Australian republicanism. Now, this may not have been a particularly notable speech - a lot of people go through the NPC, and there are quite a number of disgruntled republicans around FitzSimons' age - were it not for FitzSimons' announcement that the Treasurer, Joe Hockey, was leading a Parliamentary Friendship Group on the issue.
I suspect most of the community was not even aware of the existence of such groups. We are told that the groups exist so that members of both major parties can discuss issues that they share positions on. Apart from the question of why MPs need such groups to discuss issues with members of other parties (surely a sign of our Parliament having descended into petty sport, if further proof was needed), the elephant-in-the-room question is why now?
For starters, the republican movement is not doing particularly well at the moment. The most recent poll done on the issue, from Newspoll last year, shows that republicanism has been trending downwards since the 1999 referendum, and is now neck and neck with monarchism. Most worryingly for the movement, the level of strong support has significantly ebbed, especially amongst the young. The largest amount of strong support comes from middle-aged men (like FitzSimons and Hockey).
I suspect there are two reasons for the lack of strong support among the young. Firstly, they do not remember the bad old days for the monarchy during the 90s, particularly between the annus horribilus and the death of Princess Diana. Secondly, they're quite taken with the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, to say nothing of Prince Harry, quite possibly the only royal today who could become Governor-General of this country without too much fuss being made (not that he will). The young royals also make their older relatives look better. I suspect even Charles is more popular today than he was a decade ago. (Note: these are not the only reasons for young people (or older people) to support a monarchy, but they do help explain the changing levels of support.)
Maybe it's this waning republican fervour that has avowed republicans determined to make it an issue again, presumably thinking that as long as young Australians are made to think about the issue, that the 'incontrovertible logic' of an Australian republic will easily turn them to the cause. Given that young Australians also care less for democracy than any other age group, I'm not so sure this is the case.
If it is this desire to get republicanism waxing again before its too late, then there is still the question of why, specifically, right now? This was the week which the Treasurer began by announcing that he would be focusing on cutting income tax, and began setting out the case for such a move, explaining why it was that this must be done and why it must happen now. What logic is there in announcing this policy, proclaiming that it is important, and then two days later allowing another topic - one which has neither widespread support nor a pressing need to happen right now - to distract from this supposedly important issue?
The thing is, even the issue of income tax cuts appears to be a distraction. The case for it is not strong. Yes, bracket creep is an issue - a given when tax brackets do not keep pace with inflation - but it isn't one that is going to change the fundamentals of the economy (which are in desperate need of attention). Nor, in the short term, does it do anything for the deficit, which the government promised to deal with, or assist public services, which every federal government continues to expand, therefore requiring a larger tax base. If the money isn't coming from a healthy economy or income tax, where will it come from?
Furthermore, who benefits the most from cutting the income tax? At face value, this depends on how it is delivered. If it is simply from increasing the tax-free threshold, then anyone on the edge of a tax bracket benefits, from the poorest to the richest. If it is actually about cutting rates, then the government is presumably most interested in using it to gain votes from middle-income earners - but there's also no way they wouldn't then also cut the taxes of high earners, as that would just give the latter more incentive to take their earnings offshore (and also stop donating to their traditional party of choice). Given high earners are, by design, the largest individual contributors to the government collections of tax, this would create a shortfall that needs to be made up somewhere.
At another level, though, any income tax cut is likely to hit the affect the poor the most, not directly, but through indirect results. The shortfall can be made up in two ways: increasing income and reducing spending. Increasing income can only come from some other form of taxation which, given this government's record, is unlikely to be a form of company tax. Instead, it will likely be some other form of individual taxation, which isn't reliant on income. The thing is, flat taxation naturally affects the poorest more than it affects the richest, as it takes away a higher proportion of their wealth. This will essentially mean that cutting income tax will be a redistribution of taxation away from the rich towards the poor. Reducing spending can only come through cutting the amount of things the government does - that is, government services - which, proportionally, are also most used by the poorer. So, this important policy is simply a way of changing the degree to which wealth is redistributed amongst the population. It does nothing to change the structure of the economy. Or, to put it another way, it's a distraction.
The republican issue served to distract from the distraction of income tax cuts. Is it any wonder so many seem disenchanted with the government?
I suspect most of the community was not even aware of the existence of such groups. We are told that the groups exist so that members of both major parties can discuss issues that they share positions on. Apart from the question of why MPs need such groups to discuss issues with members of other parties (surely a sign of our Parliament having descended into petty sport, if further proof was needed), the elephant-in-the-room question is why now?
For starters, the republican movement is not doing particularly well at the moment. The most recent poll done on the issue, from Newspoll last year, shows that republicanism has been trending downwards since the 1999 referendum, and is now neck and neck with monarchism. Most worryingly for the movement, the level of strong support has significantly ebbed, especially amongst the young. The largest amount of strong support comes from middle-aged men (like FitzSimons and Hockey).
I suspect there are two reasons for the lack of strong support among the young. Firstly, they do not remember the bad old days for the monarchy during the 90s, particularly between the annus horribilus and the death of Princess Diana. Secondly, they're quite taken with the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, to say nothing of Prince Harry, quite possibly the only royal today who could become Governor-General of this country without too much fuss being made (not that he will). The young royals also make their older relatives look better. I suspect even Charles is more popular today than he was a decade ago. (Note: these are not the only reasons for young people (or older people) to support a monarchy, but they do help explain the changing levels of support.)
Maybe it's this waning republican fervour that has avowed republicans determined to make it an issue again, presumably thinking that as long as young Australians are made to think about the issue, that the 'incontrovertible logic' of an Australian republic will easily turn them to the cause. Given that young Australians also care less for democracy than any other age group, I'm not so sure this is the case.
If it is this desire to get republicanism waxing again before its too late, then there is still the question of why, specifically, right now? This was the week which the Treasurer began by announcing that he would be focusing on cutting income tax, and began setting out the case for such a move, explaining why it was that this must be done and why it must happen now. What logic is there in announcing this policy, proclaiming that it is important, and then two days later allowing another topic - one which has neither widespread support nor a pressing need to happen right now - to distract from this supposedly important issue?
The thing is, even the issue of income tax cuts appears to be a distraction. The case for it is not strong. Yes, bracket creep is an issue - a given when tax brackets do not keep pace with inflation - but it isn't one that is going to change the fundamentals of the economy (which are in desperate need of attention). Nor, in the short term, does it do anything for the deficit, which the government promised to deal with, or assist public services, which every federal government continues to expand, therefore requiring a larger tax base. If the money isn't coming from a healthy economy or income tax, where will it come from?
Furthermore, who benefits the most from cutting the income tax? At face value, this depends on how it is delivered. If it is simply from increasing the tax-free threshold, then anyone on the edge of a tax bracket benefits, from the poorest to the richest. If it is actually about cutting rates, then the government is presumably most interested in using it to gain votes from middle-income earners - but there's also no way they wouldn't then also cut the taxes of high earners, as that would just give the latter more incentive to take their earnings offshore (and also stop donating to their traditional party of choice). Given high earners are, by design, the largest individual contributors to the government collections of tax, this would create a shortfall that needs to be made up somewhere.
At another level, though, any income tax cut is likely to hit the affect the poor the most, not directly, but through indirect results. The shortfall can be made up in two ways: increasing income and reducing spending. Increasing income can only come from some other form of taxation which, given this government's record, is unlikely to be a form of company tax. Instead, it will likely be some other form of individual taxation, which isn't reliant on income. The thing is, flat taxation naturally affects the poorest more than it affects the richest, as it takes away a higher proportion of their wealth. This will essentially mean that cutting income tax will be a redistribution of taxation away from the rich towards the poor. Reducing spending can only come through cutting the amount of things the government does - that is, government services - which, proportionally, are also most used by the poorer. So, this important policy is simply a way of changing the degree to which wealth is redistributed amongst the population. It does nothing to change the structure of the economy. Or, to put it another way, it's a distraction.
The republican issue served to distract from the distraction of income tax cuts. Is it any wonder so many seem disenchanted with the government?
Monday, 20 July 2015
Rallies for drowning out voices
Over the past two days rallies were held across the country by a number of groups, some of which are protesting a shift (real or imagined) in the culture of their nation, and others which are protesting their protest.
You can tell from the names of these groups which one is which, and they have been split into two sides by the media, for your easy consumption. On the 'right', Reclaim Australia and the United Patriots Front. On the 'left', Rally Against Racism and United Against Islamophobia, supported by socialist and university groups.
I would love to be able to pronounce judgement in some form or another on which of these groups had a valid point. Unfortunately, I cannot. The media coverage of these events has been completely lacking in any form of substance, focusing almost entirely on 'clashes' with basically all of the pictures taken involving either people bellowing at others and/or policemen looking stern.
The problem with focusing on these basically irrelevant incidents is that it entirely takes away from the point of these rallies. Or, at least, the point of the Reclaim Australia rallies. It's quite remarkable how the ABC in particular managed to quote the counter-protesters far more than the initial ralliers, to the point where what the rallies were about was lost amongst the cries of racism and hate speech and the like.
From what I can gather, though, I find the claims of the counter-protesters somewhat dubious.
Reclaim Australia and other like-minded groups can fall into one of two categories: nationalists, or fascists. The best place to look to find which they may be is Europe, which is well ahead of us in terms of national discontent about immigration.
There are a large group of parties that are regularly dismissed at far-right, racist, fascist, violent, hateful etc. Some of these parties are, some of them are not, some of them might be but have conflicting messages. For example, the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) is clearly not a racist party. It has repeatedly stated that immigration is fine, but mass immigration and a lack of border control is not. Golden Dawn, the third largest party in the Greek parliament, clearly is a racist party, and though it rejects the label of Nazism it is happy to display very similar elements to the Nazis, from its logo to its rallies to its beliefs. France's National Front probably isn't, but the legacy of its former (now outcast) leader Jean-Marie Le Pen has all but guaranteed that the connection between the party and anti-Semitism will stick for years to come. Hungary's Jobbik possibly is, and undoubtedly has elements within its party that are, but at the very least seems fairly happy to let such elements support them without giving them support back.
Despite the great difference between these parties (and the fact that they all disagree with each other in the European Parliament) all have been denounced with the same language domestically and internationally. Is this wise? It seems to me that if you denounce a party and its supporters as racists, when they are not and their policies suggest otherwise, all you do is fuel tensions, and further their anger at the political climate of their nation. Take it far enough, and it could well become a self-fulfilling prophecy, though it seems unlikely to happen here.
Should Australia's economy tank (it will), chances are there will be far more community discontent and, therefore, many more people joining in rallies like that of Reclaim Australia. Right now, these rallies don't need a great deal of attention, but the public needs to be informed about them properly, to ensure that there is an understanding across the community of the genuine will of the people. If discontent rises, it cannot continually be dismissed as far-right fantasy. For now, let us observe what happens, and if we will indeed follow the Europeans with genuine concerns over immigration, or whether we will instead go our own way. Whatever we do, let us not dismiss today's events, and what they could mean for the future.
You can tell from the names of these groups which one is which, and they have been split into two sides by the media, for your easy consumption. On the 'right', Reclaim Australia and the United Patriots Front. On the 'left', Rally Against Racism and United Against Islamophobia, supported by socialist and university groups.
I would love to be able to pronounce judgement in some form or another on which of these groups had a valid point. Unfortunately, I cannot. The media coverage of these events has been completely lacking in any form of substance, focusing almost entirely on 'clashes' with basically all of the pictures taken involving either people bellowing at others and/or policemen looking stern.
The problem with focusing on these basically irrelevant incidents is that it entirely takes away from the point of these rallies. Or, at least, the point of the Reclaim Australia rallies. It's quite remarkable how the ABC in particular managed to quote the counter-protesters far more than the initial ralliers, to the point where what the rallies were about was lost amongst the cries of racism and hate speech and the like.
From what I can gather, though, I find the claims of the counter-protesters somewhat dubious.
Reclaim Australia and other like-minded groups can fall into one of two categories: nationalists, or fascists. The best place to look to find which they may be is Europe, which is well ahead of us in terms of national discontent about immigration.
There are a large group of parties that are regularly dismissed at far-right, racist, fascist, violent, hateful etc. Some of these parties are, some of them are not, some of them might be but have conflicting messages. For example, the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) is clearly not a racist party. It has repeatedly stated that immigration is fine, but mass immigration and a lack of border control is not. Golden Dawn, the third largest party in the Greek parliament, clearly is a racist party, and though it rejects the label of Nazism it is happy to display very similar elements to the Nazis, from its logo to its rallies to its beliefs. France's National Front probably isn't, but the legacy of its former (now outcast) leader Jean-Marie Le Pen has all but guaranteed that the connection between the party and anti-Semitism will stick for years to come. Hungary's Jobbik possibly is, and undoubtedly has elements within its party that are, but at the very least seems fairly happy to let such elements support them without giving them support back.
Despite the great difference between these parties (and the fact that they all disagree with each other in the European Parliament) all have been denounced with the same language domestically and internationally. Is this wise? It seems to me that if you denounce a party and its supporters as racists, when they are not and their policies suggest otherwise, all you do is fuel tensions, and further their anger at the political climate of their nation. Take it far enough, and it could well become a self-fulfilling prophecy, though it seems unlikely to happen here.
Should Australia's economy tank (it will), chances are there will be far more community discontent and, therefore, many more people joining in rallies like that of Reclaim Australia. Right now, these rallies don't need a great deal of attention, but the public needs to be informed about them properly, to ensure that there is an understanding across the community of the genuine will of the people. If discontent rises, it cannot continually be dismissed as far-right fantasy. For now, let us observe what happens, and if we will indeed follow the Europeans with genuine concerns over immigration, or whether we will instead go our own way. Whatever we do, let us not dismiss today's events, and what they could mean for the future.
Friday, 5 June 2015
Australia's economy: A disaster waiting to happen
On Wednesday we were told that the economic figures that came out were stronger than expected, thanks to some mild GDP growth.
A day later, out come the figures for Australia's trade balance. The data showed that our trade deficit is the worst on record. At no point since 1971, the year these figures go back to, has the deficit been so bad. The deficit is worse than the previous low, which was at the height of the GFC.
That should be setting off alarm bells across the country, because, as far as I'm aware, the world economy is not in meltdown. The world is meant to be recovering, even those economies worst hit that aren't called Greece, and our economy is meant to be doing relatively well. The Treasurer was eager to compare us to the other OECD economies in Question Time yesterday, in order to prove that everything is fine.
So why is our trade deficit so shockingly bad?
Well, not for the first time, we seem to have fallen the resource trap, or as it is now well known as in Canada, the Dutch disease.
Our economy has been working off the back of two things: mining and services. These are the classic symptoms of Dutch disease. To meet the demand for our rocks, labour moved from our lagging manufacturing and agricultural sectors towards mining. Then, as our economy became richer, the increase in spending meant a greater demand for services, thus creating a shift in labour from the lagging sectors towards services. Our stronger currency increases the cost of buying these services as well.
Now the mining boom is well and truly over, and we have absolutely nothing else to make up the deficit.
As you may guess from looking at my profile picture, I rather like colours. There is a great resource which helps visualise how much our economy has changed is the past two decades: it's called the Atlas of Economic Complexity, and it's the work of Harvard University.
Let's compare the economic complexity of Australia in 1995 and 2013 (you can explore the charts in more detail at the links).
You can see for yourself how totally dominant mining has become. At the top you may also notice that the value of exports has increased enormously (although it is no longer as large as it was in 2013). The problem is not that mining in and of itself weakens an economy. Mining is, after all, necessary to provide us with the goods we use daily. The problem is when it becomes an overwhelming force which decimates other industries, leaving an economy in a parlous state when the mining boom ends.
This is not the only problem facing the economy. House prices have continually acted of their own accord, only moving in one direction. Up, and up, and up they've gone, thanks to a mix of low interest rates, tax breaks and deregulated lenders. Buying a home is both easy and expensive, a mix that does not bode well in a fragile economic environment.
But neither the government nor the RBA is particularly keen to do anything to change this situation too rapidly. The RBA is cautious because housing is one of the few areas of growth left in the economy. The government is cautious because any moves may well result in political and personal pain, as not only would the electorate be seriously affected, their own investments would as well.
Housing has become such a safe bet that every man and their dog is willing to buy. Household debt is at record levels, so any change in the situation could well tens of thousands of homeowners over the edge, forcing them to sell and thus causing a rapid drop in the house price. Oversupply of housing would certainly bring down the house price, but the rest of the economy probably comes with it.
Speculation isn't restricted to housing either. The stock market is acting as though nothing is wrong. As long as house prices are increasing, and stock market isn't falling off a cliff, it is easy for those in charge to pretend nothing is wrong. At worst, it just appears to be a somewhat mixed message. But the economic indicators that most impact the person on the street - unemployment, foreign investment (outside housing), growth, wages and the aforementioned exports - are going the other direction. Those in charge will not be able to pretend forever that nothing is wrong, because those the electorate will know that that is not true.
If something is not done soon, we will have a recession, and it may even be more necessary than the last.
A day later, out come the figures for Australia's trade balance. The data showed that our trade deficit is the worst on record. At no point since 1971, the year these figures go back to, has the deficit been so bad. The deficit is worse than the previous low, which was at the height of the GFC.
That should be setting off alarm bells across the country, because, as far as I'm aware, the world economy is not in meltdown. The world is meant to be recovering, even those economies worst hit that aren't called Greece, and our economy is meant to be doing relatively well. The Treasurer was eager to compare us to the other OECD economies in Question Time yesterday, in order to prove that everything is fine.
So why is our trade deficit so shockingly bad?
Well, not for the first time, we seem to have fallen the resource trap, or as it is now well known as in Canada, the Dutch disease.
Our economy has been working off the back of two things: mining and services. These are the classic symptoms of Dutch disease. To meet the demand for our rocks, labour moved from our lagging manufacturing and agricultural sectors towards mining. Then, as our economy became richer, the increase in spending meant a greater demand for services, thus creating a shift in labour from the lagging sectors towards services. Our stronger currency increases the cost of buying these services as well.
Now the mining boom is well and truly over, and we have absolutely nothing else to make up the deficit.
As you may guess from looking at my profile picture, I rather like colours. There is a great resource which helps visualise how much our economy has changed is the past two decades: it's called the Atlas of Economic Complexity, and it's the work of Harvard University.
Let's compare the economic complexity of Australia in 1995 and 2013 (you can explore the charts in more detail at the links).
![]() |
| 1995 exports |
![]() |
| 2013 exports |
You can see for yourself how totally dominant mining has become. At the top you may also notice that the value of exports has increased enormously (although it is no longer as large as it was in 2013). The problem is not that mining in and of itself weakens an economy. Mining is, after all, necessary to provide us with the goods we use daily. The problem is when it becomes an overwhelming force which decimates other industries, leaving an economy in a parlous state when the mining boom ends.
This is not the only problem facing the economy. House prices have continually acted of their own accord, only moving in one direction. Up, and up, and up they've gone, thanks to a mix of low interest rates, tax breaks and deregulated lenders. Buying a home is both easy and expensive, a mix that does not bode well in a fragile economic environment.
But neither the government nor the RBA is particularly keen to do anything to change this situation too rapidly. The RBA is cautious because housing is one of the few areas of growth left in the economy. The government is cautious because any moves may well result in political and personal pain, as not only would the electorate be seriously affected, their own investments would as well.
Housing has become such a safe bet that every man and their dog is willing to buy. Household debt is at record levels, so any change in the situation could well tens of thousands of homeowners over the edge, forcing them to sell and thus causing a rapid drop in the house price. Oversupply of housing would certainly bring down the house price, but the rest of the economy probably comes with it.
Speculation isn't restricted to housing either. The stock market is acting as though nothing is wrong. As long as house prices are increasing, and stock market isn't falling off a cliff, it is easy for those in charge to pretend nothing is wrong. At worst, it just appears to be a somewhat mixed message. But the economic indicators that most impact the person on the street - unemployment, foreign investment (outside housing), growth, wages and the aforementioned exports - are going the other direction. Those in charge will not be able to pretend forever that nothing is wrong, because those the electorate will know that that is not true.
If something is not done soon, we will have a recession, and it may even be more necessary than the last.
Thursday, 16 April 2015
Truths, lies, and the Australian federation
The lead-up to today's COAG meeting has drawn a significant amount of discussion, speculation and arguing. Despite the Prime Minister's announcement that the main topics of discussion would be "domestic violence, national security and the ice epidemic", all the talk has been about money. Specifically, the amount of money being taken from Western Australia and given to the rest of the country.
Claims about the fairness or lack thereof of the Commonwealth Grants Commission's recommendations have been flying across the Nullabor, with Western Australia feeling aggrieved at their share of GST revenue collapsing even further, down to 30c for every dollar paid. This is occurring as the mining boom has ended, with iron prices dropping to about a third of their peak price. The Western Australian government has forecast their deficit to balloon from $1.3 billion to $3 billion.
Western Australia's anger has been matched by the rest of the country, who refuse to consider any loss of revenue that would happen if the CGC's recommendations were not used. This is understandable, as dividing up a set of of money between eight parties is necessarily a zero-sum game. But over the past week there has been so much said, by the governments and the media alike, that what is truth and what is fiction has become difficult to spot.
So, it's time figure out once and for all who's telling the truth about what.
Claim: The percentage of Western Australia's revenue that it is receiving back is smaller than any other state or territory has received historically.
Response: Seems to be true. The Commonwealth Grants Commission was established in 1933 to assess claims made by the state governments to the federal government for special assistance. The way in which it has redistributed, and what it has redistributed, has changed over the years, as far as we can find, no state has ever had such a large yearly contribution to the Commonwealth distributed to other states since 1942, the year the Commonwealth government gained control of income tax and began redistributing funds to all the states.
Claim: Western Australia will have to borrow money to pay its contribution to the CGC.
Response: Probably the simplest way of putting it. The Grants Commission is making its recommendations on, amongst other things, the assumption of an iron ore price that is no longer true. The gap between the estimated iron ore price, and the real iron ore price, is expected to be a deficit of $500 million this financial year. As Western Australia is currently running a deficit, it will have to borrow more money than it had predicted to make up for the gap in GST revenue.
Claim: Western Australia has to make economic reforms before it can receive assistance.
Response: This claim, which has been made by a number of state and federal politicians, is a stretch. The federal politicians to have suggested it are those in the government who support widespread privatisation. The state politicians who have suggested it come from states who have done likewise. There are separate problems with their suggestions. The federal government has no power to tie GST to state reforms. The Grants Commission only considers the ability for a state to finance itself equal to every other state. The Commonwealth could, theoretically, offer Western Australia a tied grant, with the tie being these 'economic reforms'. But such a tie is not legally binding, and the ties are generally that the funds be spent on a specific project or area, not that it would be used to cut a deficit on the condition of policy changes. Besides, the WA government would never agree to such a grant in the first place.
The state governments are not in any position to tell another state how they should be run, particularly when their 'economic reforms' haven't been the reason they have stayed afloat recently. In the case of some states, they have only stayed afloat because of revenue taken from better performing states...such as Western Australia. The reforms in question tend to be the dreams of the neoliberal: further deregulation of trading hours and selling of state assets. Neither of these would fix the deficit in the short term, and would cause problems in the long term. There is also a certain irony in Labor governments telling a Liberal/National government to privatise their assets.
Claim: Western Australia is only complaining now that the boom is over.
Response: Not true. Western Australia has been warning the rest of the country of the potential consequences of this method of equalisation since at least 2008. But, because WA was doing so well, it was ignored.
Claim: Western Australia has wasted its boom and is now getting its just desserts.
Response: Has Western Australia misspent its revenue during the boom? If so, on what? The answer is pretty simple: infrastructure. In 2006, Western Australia was estimated to have a population of 2 million. As of now, that number is around 2.6 million. The mining boom brought a massive number of people to the state, and the wealth being generated elsewhere had to be provided for. WA's infrastructure was not yet ready for this. In many regional areas of the state, local infrastructure had been neglected for decades. The WA Nationals successfully ran on a scheme of 'Royalties for Regions', which guaranteed that a proportion of mining royalties would be spent in regional areas, bringing their infrastructure up to scratch. The cost of doing this cannot be underestimated, as any quick scan of an atlas might show you. The cost of delivering services in Western Australia is the second highest in the nation, behind the Northern Territory. In Perth, too, billions has been and is still being spent on infrastructure projects. Much of this has been to cope with a population that has just reached 2 million, up from 1.5 million in 2006. This cannot be rightly claimed to be a misspending of finances Many of these projects also bring the city up to speed with its rivals in the eastern states, which brings us to our next claim...
Claim: The GST distribution is fair/The GST distribution is not fair.
Response: Each side is claiming 'fairness' is on their side. Indeed, fairness is the whole point of the CGC and its distribution process. Specifically, the CGC states its aim is that:
"State governments should receive funding from the pool of GST revenue such that...each would have the fiscal capacity to provide services and the associated infrastructure at the same standard..."
In essence, each state should be able to provide the same services as each other. This is, in actual fact, what the Western Australian government has been doing. Two new hospitals, a new stadium, better public transport and a city waterfront centre in the capital, matching what other capital cities have. The regions, meanwhile, have had their services brought up to the kind of standard expected in bigger regional centres. This is exactly what the CGC redistribution is meant to do. Except the Western Australian government has done it despite, not because of, the redistribution. WA bringing itself up to speed with the rest of the country is entirely of its own doing, and now it is, perversely, being punished for it.
On the other hand, there is reason to claim that a changing of the distribution now is unfair, given that (in theory) the redistribution should, in some way, balance out over time. But that is rather shaky ground to stand on, as it assumes that everything else will remain equal. We all know that no such thing happens.
Claim: Western Australia thought the boom would never end and failed to see this situation coming.
Response: The WA government knew the boom would end, and, as stated earlier, foresaw the potential pitfalls of the GST redistribution well before this year. But no-one expected the drop-off in iron ore revenue to be quite as large as it has been, and here it can be argued that WA had a misstep, in that they thought the boom would end more gradually than it has. There were budget preparations already, but the speed at which further infrastructure projects have had to be held back shows that the end of the boom came quickly. Really, though, they should have accounted for the possibility of a quick end to the boom. The resources sector is hardly renowned for stability.
Claim: Western Australia is being greedy/the eastern states are being greedy.
Response: The claims here are slightly different. The claim against Western Australia is that they had their fair share during, and now want even more. This is a very basic way to try and understand a complex issue, and we have already examined the concept of fairness. But, again, why should Western Australia be punished for creating wealth in a state where providing services comes at a high cost?
The claim against the eastern states is that they are only looking short term. But who can blame them? The budget of the WA government is not their responsibility, and they only need to be interested in what affects their state. This may have consequences in the long term for them, but it is unlikely any state will be affected as badly as WA has. In the short term, their only interest is getting the greatest win possible in a zero sum game.
Claim: The states need to sort it out amongst themselves, as it is not a federal responsibility.
Response: This statement, which has been said by a number of government ministers over the last week, makes no sense. GST distribution is done by the federal government, as GST is collected by the Australian Tax Office and redistributed to the states according to the federal government's CGC. It is the very definition of a federal responsibility. If the federal government does not want this responsibility, then they should be considering wider tax reform which frees the states to not be reliant on federal government income. Until then, the federal government must take responsibility for this issue.
Claim: Western Australia has benefited from Commonwealth grants for decades and is now being hypocritical.
Response: This is probably the crux of every claim being made. Ultimately, it comes down history, as it's your knowledge of history that will affect the way you view the present. This idea that Western Australia has been a beneficiary from federal government redistribution for most of its history is a well-worn and oft-repeated one. One article from The Drum on this matter essentially made this point, in a way that is as patronising as possible. Many internet commentators have been saying similar things. So, is it true?
It is true that Western Australia has received Commonwealth grants for much of its history. If we simply viewed this in isolation, that would be that. Of course, it isn't that simple. Prior to federation, WA was actually a thriving colony, although it had taken a while to get there. Post federation, WA's economy slumped so badly that a Royal Commission was called to figure out what had gone so wrong. The answer? Federation.
Yes, the federation that WA had cautiously joined had turned out to have an enormous negative impact on the WA economy. The Commonwealth had in place a strong system of protectionism, which was great if you had an economy that didn't rely heavily on exports. Western Australia, however, had an economy that heavily relied on exports. The reason that Western Australia was being granted funds by the federal government had little to do with Western Australia - it was essentially compensation for being hit hard by tariffs and restrictions on free trade. This is no surprise when you keep in mind how WA essentially had to lured into joining the federation with constitutional oddities (eg. section 95) and assorted promises.
So, for many years Western Australia was punished for the nature of its economy, not because of its own failures. But then there's the claim that it's only been since the mining boom began that Western Australia started paying its own way. This, too, is false. Western Australia has been a net donor to the federation since the 1980s, arguably since even earlier.
Certainly, since the removal of protectionism, the state has been able to pay its way. The claim that WA is just being silly and should pipe down, which is often the gist of many of the claims made, is massively unhelpful.
What this argy-bargy is clearly demonstrating, above all, is that the current distribution of wealth between governments is not right, and widespread reform is necessary. A band-aid solution will not fix the current situation.
Claims about the fairness or lack thereof of the Commonwealth Grants Commission's recommendations have been flying across the Nullabor, with Western Australia feeling aggrieved at their share of GST revenue collapsing even further, down to 30c for every dollar paid. This is occurring as the mining boom has ended, with iron prices dropping to about a third of their peak price. The Western Australian government has forecast their deficit to balloon from $1.3 billion to $3 billion.
Western Australia's anger has been matched by the rest of the country, who refuse to consider any loss of revenue that would happen if the CGC's recommendations were not used. This is understandable, as dividing up a set of of money between eight parties is necessarily a zero-sum game. But over the past week there has been so much said, by the governments and the media alike, that what is truth and what is fiction has become difficult to spot.
So, it's time figure out once and for all who's telling the truth about what.
Claim: The percentage of Western Australia's revenue that it is receiving back is smaller than any other state or territory has received historically.
Response: Seems to be true. The Commonwealth Grants Commission was established in 1933 to assess claims made by the state governments to the federal government for special assistance. The way in which it has redistributed, and what it has redistributed, has changed over the years, as far as we can find, no state has ever had such a large yearly contribution to the Commonwealth distributed to other states since 1942, the year the Commonwealth government gained control of income tax and began redistributing funds to all the states.
Claim: Western Australia will have to borrow money to pay its contribution to the CGC.
Response: Probably the simplest way of putting it. The Grants Commission is making its recommendations on, amongst other things, the assumption of an iron ore price that is no longer true. The gap between the estimated iron ore price, and the real iron ore price, is expected to be a deficit of $500 million this financial year. As Western Australia is currently running a deficit, it will have to borrow more money than it had predicted to make up for the gap in GST revenue.
Claim: Western Australia has to make economic reforms before it can receive assistance.
Response: This claim, which has been made by a number of state and federal politicians, is a stretch. The federal politicians to have suggested it are those in the government who support widespread privatisation. The state politicians who have suggested it come from states who have done likewise. There are separate problems with their suggestions. The federal government has no power to tie GST to state reforms. The Grants Commission only considers the ability for a state to finance itself equal to every other state. The Commonwealth could, theoretically, offer Western Australia a tied grant, with the tie being these 'economic reforms'. But such a tie is not legally binding, and the ties are generally that the funds be spent on a specific project or area, not that it would be used to cut a deficit on the condition of policy changes. Besides, the WA government would never agree to such a grant in the first place.
The state governments are not in any position to tell another state how they should be run, particularly when their 'economic reforms' haven't been the reason they have stayed afloat recently. In the case of some states, they have only stayed afloat because of revenue taken from better performing states...such as Western Australia. The reforms in question tend to be the dreams of the neoliberal: further deregulation of trading hours and selling of state assets. Neither of these would fix the deficit in the short term, and would cause problems in the long term. There is also a certain irony in Labor governments telling a Liberal/National government to privatise their assets.
Claim: Western Australia is only complaining now that the boom is over.
Response: Not true. Western Australia has been warning the rest of the country of the potential consequences of this method of equalisation since at least 2008. But, because WA was doing so well, it was ignored.
Claim: Western Australia has wasted its boom and is now getting its just desserts.
Response: Has Western Australia misspent its revenue during the boom? If so, on what? The answer is pretty simple: infrastructure. In 2006, Western Australia was estimated to have a population of 2 million. As of now, that number is around 2.6 million. The mining boom brought a massive number of people to the state, and the wealth being generated elsewhere had to be provided for. WA's infrastructure was not yet ready for this. In many regional areas of the state, local infrastructure had been neglected for decades. The WA Nationals successfully ran on a scheme of 'Royalties for Regions', which guaranteed that a proportion of mining royalties would be spent in regional areas, bringing their infrastructure up to scratch. The cost of doing this cannot be underestimated, as any quick scan of an atlas might show you. The cost of delivering services in Western Australia is the second highest in the nation, behind the Northern Territory. In Perth, too, billions has been and is still being spent on infrastructure projects. Much of this has been to cope with a population that has just reached 2 million, up from 1.5 million in 2006. This cannot be rightly claimed to be a misspending of finances Many of these projects also bring the city up to speed with its rivals in the eastern states, which brings us to our next claim...
Claim: The GST distribution is fair/The GST distribution is not fair.
Response: Each side is claiming 'fairness' is on their side. Indeed, fairness is the whole point of the CGC and its distribution process. Specifically, the CGC states its aim is that:
"State governments should receive funding from the pool of GST revenue such that...each would have the fiscal capacity to provide services and the associated infrastructure at the same standard..."
In essence, each state should be able to provide the same services as each other. This is, in actual fact, what the Western Australian government has been doing. Two new hospitals, a new stadium, better public transport and a city waterfront centre in the capital, matching what other capital cities have. The regions, meanwhile, have had their services brought up to the kind of standard expected in bigger regional centres. This is exactly what the CGC redistribution is meant to do. Except the Western Australian government has done it despite, not because of, the redistribution. WA bringing itself up to speed with the rest of the country is entirely of its own doing, and now it is, perversely, being punished for it.
On the other hand, there is reason to claim that a changing of the distribution now is unfair, given that (in theory) the redistribution should, in some way, balance out over time. But that is rather shaky ground to stand on, as it assumes that everything else will remain equal. We all know that no such thing happens.
Claim: Western Australia thought the boom would never end and failed to see this situation coming.
Response: The WA government knew the boom would end, and, as stated earlier, foresaw the potential pitfalls of the GST redistribution well before this year. But no-one expected the drop-off in iron ore revenue to be quite as large as it has been, and here it can be argued that WA had a misstep, in that they thought the boom would end more gradually than it has. There were budget preparations already, but the speed at which further infrastructure projects have had to be held back shows that the end of the boom came quickly. Really, though, they should have accounted for the possibility of a quick end to the boom. The resources sector is hardly renowned for stability.
Claim: Western Australia is being greedy/the eastern states are being greedy.
Response: The claims here are slightly different. The claim against Western Australia is that they had their fair share during, and now want even more. This is a very basic way to try and understand a complex issue, and we have already examined the concept of fairness. But, again, why should Western Australia be punished for creating wealth in a state where providing services comes at a high cost?
The claim against the eastern states is that they are only looking short term. But who can blame them? The budget of the WA government is not their responsibility, and they only need to be interested in what affects their state. This may have consequences in the long term for them, but it is unlikely any state will be affected as badly as WA has. In the short term, their only interest is getting the greatest win possible in a zero sum game.
Claim: The states need to sort it out amongst themselves, as it is not a federal responsibility.
Response: This statement, which has been said by a number of government ministers over the last week, makes no sense. GST distribution is done by the federal government, as GST is collected by the Australian Tax Office and redistributed to the states according to the federal government's CGC. It is the very definition of a federal responsibility. If the federal government does not want this responsibility, then they should be considering wider tax reform which frees the states to not be reliant on federal government income. Until then, the federal government must take responsibility for this issue.
Claim: Western Australia has benefited from Commonwealth grants for decades and is now being hypocritical.
Response: This is probably the crux of every claim being made. Ultimately, it comes down history, as it's your knowledge of history that will affect the way you view the present. This idea that Western Australia has been a beneficiary from federal government redistribution for most of its history is a well-worn and oft-repeated one. One article from The Drum on this matter essentially made this point, in a way that is as patronising as possible. Many internet commentators have been saying similar things. So, is it true?
It is true that Western Australia has received Commonwealth grants for much of its history. If we simply viewed this in isolation, that would be that. Of course, it isn't that simple. Prior to federation, WA was actually a thriving colony, although it had taken a while to get there. Post federation, WA's economy slumped so badly that a Royal Commission was called to figure out what had gone so wrong. The answer? Federation.
Yes, the federation that WA had cautiously joined had turned out to have an enormous negative impact on the WA economy. The Commonwealth had in place a strong system of protectionism, which was great if you had an economy that didn't rely heavily on exports. Western Australia, however, had an economy that heavily relied on exports. The reason that Western Australia was being granted funds by the federal government had little to do with Western Australia - it was essentially compensation for being hit hard by tariffs and restrictions on free trade. This is no surprise when you keep in mind how WA essentially had to lured into joining the federation with constitutional oddities (eg. section 95) and assorted promises.
So, for many years Western Australia was punished for the nature of its economy, not because of its own failures. But then there's the claim that it's only been since the mining boom began that Western Australia started paying its own way. This, too, is false. Western Australia has been a net donor to the federation since the 1980s, arguably since even earlier.
Certainly, since the removal of protectionism, the state has been able to pay its way. The claim that WA is just being silly and should pipe down, which is often the gist of many of the claims made, is massively unhelpful.
What this argy-bargy is clearly demonstrating, above all, is that the current distribution of wealth between governments is not right, and widespread reform is necessary. A band-aid solution will not fix the current situation.
Thursday, 26 March 2015
Malcolm Fraser, media confounder
The sudden passing of Malcolm Fraser, Australia's 22nd Prime Minister, has resulted in journalists across the nation scribbling away furiously in their attempts to summarise the man's political life.
These summaries have all covered similar ground in trying to explain Fraser. 'Fraser transformed himself from the patrician Liberal...to a vocal proponent for progressive causes often at odds with his own party.' said the Guardian. News stated that he 'a public transformation occurred after he lost office,' as did the Conversation, more than once. Yahoo7 claimed he became 'an unlikely hero of the Left.' InDaily called him a 'paradox'.
So, what is it about Fraser that seems to have confounded the media? Why did Miranda Devine describe him as having moved 'from extreme right to extreme left'? Well, I can't explain all of that, as I do not know how anything Fraser did could be described as either, but the gist of what she is saying is what they're all saying - he was a PM on the 'right', and once he retired he became 'left'.
So, what did Fraser do?
Firstly, let's look at his record as Prime Minister. Economically, Fraser was expected at the time to be part of the emerging neo-liberal dominance across the West, and criticism of him at the time was along these lines. In hindsight, this didn't occur. In actual fact, Fraser was a moderating force against neo-liberal elements within his party and the public service. Fraser, like many politicians of his immediate post-war era, had a Keynesian economic view, which he blended with classic liberal beliefs. This kind of in-between position meant that his public service cuts were too big to some, and not big enough to others. Medibank was not eradicated, but slowly dismantled. Family benefits came in as tax rebates for dependent children were abolished. Government spending slowed, but never deliberately shrunk.
On deregulation, Fraser's government was more pliant. Exchange rates, interest rates, foreign bank entries and control over capital movements were all deregulated under Fraser's government to some degree. None of these were total, and in actual fact it took until the Hawke/Keating duumvirate came into power before these were completed. But it was under Fraser that these plans got going, before the Treasury and Reserve Bank thought it was necessary.
By today's standards, none of this can be considered especially 'right'. Furthermore, even at the time he was at odds with younger members of his party (including Treasurer John Howard) who wanted harder cuts. The gently, gently approach to economics has been argued as one of the reasons the economy collapsed in Fraser's later years. But the fact that it was a Labor government who managed to push through deregulation, and a Liberal government avoided doing so, suggests that perhaps the difference between the parties isn't as clear as it often stated.
When it comes to social policies, Fraser's strengths were in areas that weren't overly politicised at the time. Human rights (especially for Aborigines) and immigration issues were not a source of political division. For the most part, Fraser carried on where the Whitlam government had left off, who had in turn carried on from the previous Liberal governments. In fact, immigration and human rights had never been a particularly partisan issue. After all, the union movement was a strong supporter of the White Australia policy. As the policy was removed, the parties moved as well. It is only in recent years that it has become an issue that the parties heavily disagree on.
That's not to say there weren't elements who disagreed with the open immigration policies of the Fraser government. But, interestingly, those elements didn't come from his party, but from the public service. It was the Department of Immigration who first became alarmed about people arriving by boat, and suggested that the boats either be stopped before they arrived, or that those arriving be sent to a 'reception centre', as they were 'queue jumpers'. Cabinet did not take these suggestions up.
He was also an early environmentalist, successfully protecting Kakadu, Fraser Island and the Great Barrier Reef with certain policies. This, again, is supposedly at odds with today's 'right'. He also pushed for the Franklin River to be protected from damming, although this was also something not completed until the Hawke government.
These economic and social policies followed Fraser into foreign policy. He pushed for free trade, which Australia needed as an raw material exporter, while also taking the forefront in promoting majority rule in Rhodesia.
Fraser's time as Prime Minister, then, may actually be a bit confusing for anyone trying to view it under the lens of the left-right spectrum. Economically, he attempting to walk the line between liberalism and Keynesianism. Socially, he focused on issues that were, at the time, bilateral, and today are arguably leaning to the 'left'. Despite this, it's claimed he was just another typical 'right' politician. This suggests either collective memory loss, or a failure in the portrayal of our politics.
But there was more to this. Fraser was meant to have moved from 'right' to 'left' after leaving the Parliament. We know he already wasn't 'right' in Parliament, but did he change his beliefs after leaving anyway?
Put simply - no. Fraser rarely commented on economic matters after he left office, but his foreign policy beliefs suggested that nothing changed. But on social issues, he was vigourous in his support of human rights, working for various think tanks and becoming particularly involved in South Africa's transition away from apartheid. He became increasingly critical of the politics of Australia, especially that of his own party, regarding immigration. By 2009, he had had enough, and left the Liberals after Malcolm Turnbull lost the leadership.
One area that he did move on was his policy towards the US. During the Cold War, he was suspicious of the USSR and not a supporter of detente, allying himself to the US and previous governments had. But in later life he began suggesting that Australia move away from its close ties with the US, instead being a more independent nation. In actuality, this fits in well with his foreign policy in office, which attempted to place Australia in a greater position in world politics. This is also about as close as it gets to a movement to the 'left'.
There have been suggestions that the Liberal Party moved away from Fraser, which is a reasonable argument. Neo-liberalism has slowly taken root without the party, though there's always the sense that there are plenty of members that aren't huge fans of it. Human rights issues, on the other hand, have become major partisan issues, which has changed the nature of politics in this country.
But this does not account for the initial description of Fraser as being of the 'right'. Fraser's classic liberalism meant he was, at the time, a natural member of the Liberal Party - but the Liberal Party was not always 'right' in the same way it is implied. That Fraser should be suggested to be such is a failure of the left-right spectrum, and as long as it is used, the media will be unable to grasp the nature of liberalism correctly.
These summaries have all covered similar ground in trying to explain Fraser. 'Fraser transformed himself from the patrician Liberal...to a vocal proponent for progressive causes often at odds with his own party.' said the Guardian. News stated that he 'a public transformation occurred after he lost office,' as did the Conversation, more than once. Yahoo7 claimed he became 'an unlikely hero of the Left.' InDaily called him a 'paradox'.
So, what is it about Fraser that seems to have confounded the media? Why did Miranda Devine describe him as having moved 'from extreme right to extreme left'? Well, I can't explain all of that, as I do not know how anything Fraser did could be described as either, but the gist of what she is saying is what they're all saying - he was a PM on the 'right', and once he retired he became 'left'.
So, what did Fraser do?
Firstly, let's look at his record as Prime Minister. Economically, Fraser was expected at the time to be part of the emerging neo-liberal dominance across the West, and criticism of him at the time was along these lines. In hindsight, this didn't occur. In actual fact, Fraser was a moderating force against neo-liberal elements within his party and the public service. Fraser, like many politicians of his immediate post-war era, had a Keynesian economic view, which he blended with classic liberal beliefs. This kind of in-between position meant that his public service cuts were too big to some, and not big enough to others. Medibank was not eradicated, but slowly dismantled. Family benefits came in as tax rebates for dependent children were abolished. Government spending slowed, but never deliberately shrunk.
On deregulation, Fraser's government was more pliant. Exchange rates, interest rates, foreign bank entries and control over capital movements were all deregulated under Fraser's government to some degree. None of these were total, and in actual fact it took until the Hawke/Keating duumvirate came into power before these were completed. But it was under Fraser that these plans got going, before the Treasury and Reserve Bank thought it was necessary.
By today's standards, none of this can be considered especially 'right'. Furthermore, even at the time he was at odds with younger members of his party (including Treasurer John Howard) who wanted harder cuts. The gently, gently approach to economics has been argued as one of the reasons the economy collapsed in Fraser's later years. But the fact that it was a Labor government who managed to push through deregulation, and a Liberal government avoided doing so, suggests that perhaps the difference between the parties isn't as clear as it often stated.
When it comes to social policies, Fraser's strengths were in areas that weren't overly politicised at the time. Human rights (especially for Aborigines) and immigration issues were not a source of political division. For the most part, Fraser carried on where the Whitlam government had left off, who had in turn carried on from the previous Liberal governments. In fact, immigration and human rights had never been a particularly partisan issue. After all, the union movement was a strong supporter of the White Australia policy. As the policy was removed, the parties moved as well. It is only in recent years that it has become an issue that the parties heavily disagree on.
That's not to say there weren't elements who disagreed with the open immigration policies of the Fraser government. But, interestingly, those elements didn't come from his party, but from the public service. It was the Department of Immigration who first became alarmed about people arriving by boat, and suggested that the boats either be stopped before they arrived, or that those arriving be sent to a 'reception centre', as they were 'queue jumpers'. Cabinet did not take these suggestions up.
He was also an early environmentalist, successfully protecting Kakadu, Fraser Island and the Great Barrier Reef with certain policies. This, again, is supposedly at odds with today's 'right'. He also pushed for the Franklin River to be protected from damming, although this was also something not completed until the Hawke government.
These economic and social policies followed Fraser into foreign policy. He pushed for free trade, which Australia needed as an raw material exporter, while also taking the forefront in promoting majority rule in Rhodesia.
Fraser's time as Prime Minister, then, may actually be a bit confusing for anyone trying to view it under the lens of the left-right spectrum. Economically, he attempting to walk the line between liberalism and Keynesianism. Socially, he focused on issues that were, at the time, bilateral, and today are arguably leaning to the 'left'. Despite this, it's claimed he was just another typical 'right' politician. This suggests either collective memory loss, or a failure in the portrayal of our politics.
But there was more to this. Fraser was meant to have moved from 'right' to 'left' after leaving the Parliament. We know he already wasn't 'right' in Parliament, but did he change his beliefs after leaving anyway?
Put simply - no. Fraser rarely commented on economic matters after he left office, but his foreign policy beliefs suggested that nothing changed. But on social issues, he was vigourous in his support of human rights, working for various think tanks and becoming particularly involved in South Africa's transition away from apartheid. He became increasingly critical of the politics of Australia, especially that of his own party, regarding immigration. By 2009, he had had enough, and left the Liberals after Malcolm Turnbull lost the leadership.
One area that he did move on was his policy towards the US. During the Cold War, he was suspicious of the USSR and not a supporter of detente, allying himself to the US and previous governments had. But in later life he began suggesting that Australia move away from its close ties with the US, instead being a more independent nation. In actuality, this fits in well with his foreign policy in office, which attempted to place Australia in a greater position in world politics. This is also about as close as it gets to a movement to the 'left'.
There have been suggestions that the Liberal Party moved away from Fraser, which is a reasonable argument. Neo-liberalism has slowly taken root without the party, though there's always the sense that there are plenty of members that aren't huge fans of it. Human rights issues, on the other hand, have become major partisan issues, which has changed the nature of politics in this country.
But this does not account for the initial description of Fraser as being of the 'right'. Fraser's classic liberalism meant he was, at the time, a natural member of the Liberal Party - but the Liberal Party was not always 'right' in the same way it is implied. That Fraser should be suggested to be such is a failure of the left-right spectrum, and as long as it is used, the media will be unable to grasp the nature of liberalism correctly.
Wednesday, 18 March 2015
When Palmer United became a party divided
After the 2013 federal election, it appeared there was a new force in Australian politics. Clive Palmer, mining magnate and Bjelke-Petersen supporter, had run a huge campaign, storming across the nation from Queensland, like a tropical cyclone. It covered television, radio, billboards, newspapers, letterbox pamphlets and even a DVD, and it worked a treat. The Palmer United Party gained one House of Representatives member (Palmer himself in Fairfax), but more importantly appeared to hold the balance of power in the Senate, with three Senators from three states, as well as an 'informal alliance' with the newly elected Ricky Muir.
As of this week, those five MPs have dwindled to two - Palmer and WA's Dio Wang are all that are left, with Muir, Jacqui Lambie and now Glenn 'Brick With Eyes' Lazarus going their own way. The cyclone had petered out to a mild drizzle.
So what happened?
In order to understand the sudden collapse of the PUP, you must see the party for what it is. Some have claimed that the party was only ever a ruse or a front for Palmer himself, designed to allow him greater lobbying ability within the parliament, and ultimately the government. Certainly, Palmer has attempted to use the party for this at times, but it seems an overly open way of lobbying for even someone like Clive. Palmer is a clever individual - dumb like a fox, you might say - and he has decades of experience in politics behind the scenes. If he just wanted to lobby, he would just lobby.
No, it seems that Palmer was genuinely interested in some kind of party for the people. Of course, the party would have to serve his interests, but Palmer would presumably also believe that his interests are the interests of the majority of Australians. Essentially, he wanted to create a populist party that could claim to be for the people, by the people.
You can see this in the candidates that were selected. The range of backgrounds is remarkably wide, from academics to tradesmen and everything in between. But there is also the sense that in most cases they just picked whoever was willing to have a go, apart from a few hand-picked candidates.
This is an approach fraught with danger, but it didn't seem to affect their overall appeal too much. In fact, stories like their candidate in Corangamite's wild election launch party were probably just as appealing to some members of the electorate as they were unappealing to others. So, during the course of the 2013 campaign, all seemed well. The potential for disaster that exists with having independently minded candidates brought together only by dissatisfaction with current politics was hidden by the sheer breadth of the campaign. Palmer offered a simple, effective message to the public - 'reunite the nation' - and the public responded.
Even though many wondered how long Lambie would last within the party upon first hearing her opinions, things seemed to get even better for the PUP in the WA Senate election, when they received 12.34% of the vote, a remarkable amount for a minor party in Australia.
Since then, it has been downhill. Two Queensland state MPs quit the party, with one citing a culture of 'jobs for the boys'. The three Northern Territory rebel MPs who joined the party in 2014 quit soon after, due to a total lack of structure and support.
And, most crucially, two Senators announced they would be independent. Lambie and Lazarus both left after personal spats with Palmer. Muir, meanwhile, has quietly done his own thing.
In the end, it seems the problem is Clive, and the fact that everything in the party centres around him. Should a member find fault with him, they find fault with the party, and leave. This is a difficult problem to have, as Palmer is also the only reason the party exists in the first place. As is often the case when one person drives the entire party, the fortunes of the party live and die on that person's performance, which is in no way a viable long-term option.
The story of the Dutch Pim Fortuyn List is a clear example of this. Led by a populist, nationalist leader in Pim Fortuyn, the party rocketed into Government in its first election. It did this without Fortuyn, who had been assassinated during the election campaign. Without Fortuyn, and unable to use the wave of public support to govern in the same way it did to get voted in, the party fell apart. In only one year the party lost two-thirds of its vote. Three years later it barely registered at all.
So, what must the PUP do to avoid this fate? Firstly, it must change its name to what it was originally to be called - the United Australia Party. This, if only rhetorically, takes the focus off Palmer. Second, it needs to develop clear policy. Populism can only take a party so far, and often only on the back of a popular leader. As we have seen, a party based on a popular leader will not last, so the party must look to add depth of support, even if it comes at the expense of breadth of support.
Only then may the PUP be seen as a potential lasting force in Australian politics. If it does not, or cannot, do these things, it will be only a footnote in our political history.
As of this week, those five MPs have dwindled to two - Palmer and WA's Dio Wang are all that are left, with Muir, Jacqui Lambie and now Glenn 'Brick With Eyes' Lazarus going their own way. The cyclone had petered out to a mild drizzle.
So what happened?
In order to understand the sudden collapse of the PUP, you must see the party for what it is. Some have claimed that the party was only ever a ruse or a front for Palmer himself, designed to allow him greater lobbying ability within the parliament, and ultimately the government. Certainly, Palmer has attempted to use the party for this at times, but it seems an overly open way of lobbying for even someone like Clive. Palmer is a clever individual - dumb like a fox, you might say - and he has decades of experience in politics behind the scenes. If he just wanted to lobby, he would just lobby.
No, it seems that Palmer was genuinely interested in some kind of party for the people. Of course, the party would have to serve his interests, but Palmer would presumably also believe that his interests are the interests of the majority of Australians. Essentially, he wanted to create a populist party that could claim to be for the people, by the people.
You can see this in the candidates that were selected. The range of backgrounds is remarkably wide, from academics to tradesmen and everything in between. But there is also the sense that in most cases they just picked whoever was willing to have a go, apart from a few hand-picked candidates.
This is an approach fraught with danger, but it didn't seem to affect their overall appeal too much. In fact, stories like their candidate in Corangamite's wild election launch party were probably just as appealing to some members of the electorate as they were unappealing to others. So, during the course of the 2013 campaign, all seemed well. The potential for disaster that exists with having independently minded candidates brought together only by dissatisfaction with current politics was hidden by the sheer breadth of the campaign. Palmer offered a simple, effective message to the public - 'reunite the nation' - and the public responded.
Even though many wondered how long Lambie would last within the party upon first hearing her opinions, things seemed to get even better for the PUP in the WA Senate election, when they received 12.34% of the vote, a remarkable amount for a minor party in Australia.
Since then, it has been downhill. Two Queensland state MPs quit the party, with one citing a culture of 'jobs for the boys'. The three Northern Territory rebel MPs who joined the party in 2014 quit soon after, due to a total lack of structure and support.
And, most crucially, two Senators announced they would be independent. Lambie and Lazarus both left after personal spats with Palmer. Muir, meanwhile, has quietly done his own thing.
In the end, it seems the problem is Clive, and the fact that everything in the party centres around him. Should a member find fault with him, they find fault with the party, and leave. This is a difficult problem to have, as Palmer is also the only reason the party exists in the first place. As is often the case when one person drives the entire party, the fortunes of the party live and die on that person's performance, which is in no way a viable long-term option.
The story of the Dutch Pim Fortuyn List is a clear example of this. Led by a populist, nationalist leader in Pim Fortuyn, the party rocketed into Government in its first election. It did this without Fortuyn, who had been assassinated during the election campaign. Without Fortuyn, and unable to use the wave of public support to govern in the same way it did to get voted in, the party fell apart. In only one year the party lost two-thirds of its vote. Three years later it barely registered at all.
So, what must the PUP do to avoid this fate? Firstly, it must change its name to what it was originally to be called - the United Australia Party. This, if only rhetorically, takes the focus off Palmer. Second, it needs to develop clear policy. Populism can only take a party so far, and often only on the back of a popular leader. As we have seen, a party based on a popular leader will not last, so the party must look to add depth of support, even if it comes at the expense of breadth of support.
Only then may the PUP be seen as a potential lasting force in Australian politics. If it does not, or cannot, do these things, it will be only a footnote in our political history.
Thursday, 12 March 2015
The value of politicians from all walks of life
Last week, with only a little fanfare, Senator Ricky Muir gave his maiden speech in the Senate. He took nearly eight months to get around to delivering it, which may (or may not) be a record. Prior to that, he had only spoken three times in the chamber. This may suggest that Muir someone who clearly shouldn't be in the parliament, someone who doesn't belong, isn't well educated enough and doesn't have the right qualifications.
Certainly, that is the impression that has been given of Muir since his election. When it became apparent that this unknown candidate was going to gain a seat in the Senate with only 17,000 votes going to him off first preferences, the media naturally set about finding what they could about him. The first thing they found was a video of him flinging kangaroo dung around on a camping trip.
This set the tone for the way his image was shaped in the weeks following. There was precious little else to go on, so the media happily took this as proof that Muir was just some Aussie larrikin that really shouldn't be in the parliament. His first television interview, done with Mike Willesee, was also more or less a disaster. But Muir kept his head up, and continued his preparations.
As it turns out, the image of Muir as some uneducated, incapable Aussie bush bloke is, ironically, rather unrefined.
The first indication we got of this was in this piece by Sophie Morris in July last year. Muir is - surprise - a car enthusiast, but he is also more than that. He is a strong family man, he understands the value of employment to the average person, he is thoughtful, and he is independent.
He also calls himself 'just an ordinary bloke'.
Then, last week, all of these things were confirmed in his maiden speech, which you can see here:
Muir bought his first suit just for the speech. For the most part, like most people would in a similar situation, he read the pre-prepared speech word for word. There was nothing slick about it, and there wasn't any sense that Muir was there for his own interests. He was there because he cared, and because he felt a duty towards people like him.
If you read the comments below the YouTube video, you'll find that they are overwhelmingly positive, praising Muir for being authentic, humble, real and, above all, an average Australian. How many politicians would get that kind of response to a speech of theirs?
Not many in our Parliament today. Certainly, not many from the major parties. One other 'average' Australian comes to mind, though, in Jacqui Lambie. Lambie's performance in public since being elected could not be further removed from Muir's, but she receives similar positive responses for being real.
To the public, they are just ordinary Aussies.
Muir has also given every indication so far that he intends to make informed decisions in the parliament. He has sought to learn from those in the know, and he has learnt quickly. He needed to. Of all the people elected to the Senate last year, he was the one being held up as the clearest example that the Senate was not representative.
But, thanks to the way our political system works, it often turns out that those elected with the smallest proportion of votes can actually truly represent the largest number of voters. When we vote for our Senators, we vote for individuals. If we were able to meet all the people running for the Senate face-to-face, chances are it would be people like Muir who would be most positively received.
There's no doubt that a system that allows people to be elected with 0.03 of a quota on first preferences isn't quite working correctly. But it also happens to be those same quirks that allow us to have representatives who aren't beholden to behemoth parties, and who genuinely care about their constituency.
If the Senate is ever the 'unrepresentative swill' Paul Keating claimed it is, it will be when people like sawmill worker Muir, military policeman Lambie and boilermaker John Madigan are barred from entering the parliament. We must ensure this never happens.
Certainly, that is the impression that has been given of Muir since his election. When it became apparent that this unknown candidate was going to gain a seat in the Senate with only 17,000 votes going to him off first preferences, the media naturally set about finding what they could about him. The first thing they found was a video of him flinging kangaroo dung around on a camping trip.
This set the tone for the way his image was shaped in the weeks following. There was precious little else to go on, so the media happily took this as proof that Muir was just some Aussie larrikin that really shouldn't be in the parliament. His first television interview, done with Mike Willesee, was also more or less a disaster. But Muir kept his head up, and continued his preparations.
As it turns out, the image of Muir as some uneducated, incapable Aussie bush bloke is, ironically, rather unrefined.
The first indication we got of this was in this piece by Sophie Morris in July last year. Muir is - surprise - a car enthusiast, but he is also more than that. He is a strong family man, he understands the value of employment to the average person, he is thoughtful, and he is independent.
He also calls himself 'just an ordinary bloke'.
Then, last week, all of these things were confirmed in his maiden speech, which you can see here:
Muir bought his first suit just for the speech. For the most part, like most people would in a similar situation, he read the pre-prepared speech word for word. There was nothing slick about it, and there wasn't any sense that Muir was there for his own interests. He was there because he cared, and because he felt a duty towards people like him.
If you read the comments below the YouTube video, you'll find that they are overwhelmingly positive, praising Muir for being authentic, humble, real and, above all, an average Australian. How many politicians would get that kind of response to a speech of theirs?
Not many in our Parliament today. Certainly, not many from the major parties. One other 'average' Australian comes to mind, though, in Jacqui Lambie. Lambie's performance in public since being elected could not be further removed from Muir's, but she receives similar positive responses for being real.
To the public, they are just ordinary Aussies.
Muir has also given every indication so far that he intends to make informed decisions in the parliament. He has sought to learn from those in the know, and he has learnt quickly. He needed to. Of all the people elected to the Senate last year, he was the one being held up as the clearest example that the Senate was not representative.
But, thanks to the way our political system works, it often turns out that those elected with the smallest proportion of votes can actually truly represent the largest number of voters. When we vote for our Senators, we vote for individuals. If we were able to meet all the people running for the Senate face-to-face, chances are it would be people like Muir who would be most positively received.
There's no doubt that a system that allows people to be elected with 0.03 of a quota on first preferences isn't quite working correctly. But it also happens to be those same quirks that allow us to have representatives who aren't beholden to behemoth parties, and who genuinely care about their constituency.
If the Senate is ever the 'unrepresentative swill' Paul Keating claimed it is, it will be when people like sawmill worker Muir, military policeman Lambie and boilermaker John Madigan are barred from entering the parliament. We must ensure this never happens.
Thursday, 26 February 2015
The problem with Q&A politics
Q&A
has been a staple of Australia's media and political landscape
since its inception in 2008. Based on the BBC's long running Question
Time, the show has seemingly
given the public a stronger voice regarding important political,
economic and social issues. It consistently rates well for its
timeslot (around 900,000 in total), and every Monday night, like
clockwork, #QandA will be trending on Twitter.
So, it sounds like the show is a win for everyone, right?
Wrong.
There are many people who could potentially benefit from a show like
this. In theory, all Australians should be reaping the rewards of
such a show, in some way or another. Holding politicians to account,
and bringing important community issues and opinions to the forefront
should be a good thing.
But
in reality, Q&A
simply is not the broad ranging, powerful and interesting place of
discussion that it attempts to be. It does not benefit all those it
should. Most importantly, it quite often cannot break through the
increasingly bland political discourse this country is full of,
instead being a vehicle for it.
The ABC loves Q&A. And why wouldn't they? It's one of
their highest rating programmes and isn't particularly expensive to
produce. In an era when they (unfortunately) need to keep justifying
their existence, the ABC can point to Q&A as one of their
great successes. It also keeps them 'in the conversation' on social
media, which is of ever increasing value.
The other people who quite enjoy Q&A are the major parties.
Specifically, the more prominent members of these parties, some of
whom can attribute their prominence directly to their almost constant
rotation into the show. Gone are the days of Rudd and Hockey, Gillard
and Abbott being all jovial on morning television to get people to
pay attention to them. No, these days Q&A is the lightning rod
for political discussion instead – something surely confirmed by
Today host Lisa Wilkinson appearing on the show last Monday.
We've gone from politicians making small talk on morning shows to
morning show hosts having serious discussions about politics.
And when I say constant rotation, I do mean constant rotation. Of the
top ten most frequently appearing guests (to the end of 2014), nine
of them were part of either the ALP or the Coalition. Of the top
twenty, seventeen are from the two majors. The remaining three are
two journalists from The Australian (Janet Albrechtsen and
Greg Sheridan) and the leader of the Greens, Christine Milne. Of the
44 episodes to air in 2014, 28 featured a member from both of the
major parties. Of the remaining 16, three were one-person specials
(of which two of those featured government ministers) and eleven were
specials focusing on a particular topic, mostly featuring people
relevant to the topic. That leaves a whole two 'regular' episodes of
five panellists talking about the big issues of the week.
To be fair to the ABC, they do seem to have tried a bit harder in
recent years to make sure that people outside of the major parties
are the focus of episodes from time to time. Thirteen episodes with a
member from each of the major parties is a significant step up from
2010, where only four of the 41 episodes featured a five member panel
and did not include two major party politicians. But it's still not
enough. By making the specials into the episodes without the majors,
it places the episodes with the majors as the status quo, and,
politically speaking, that is the problem.
There is not necessarily anything wrong with having politicians on
the show regularly. In fact, it is a good thing that they are willing
to show up and answer questions, especially members of the
government. But there is something wrong with having one from each
party on the show basically every week. The problem is this: it
reinforces the idea of two parties in total opposition to one
another. Q&A is not at fault for this idea gaining
traction – it is embedded into the current Australian political
system – but the programme does little to challenge it either. For
example, last week's show saw Jamie Briggs (Assistant Infrastructure
Minister) and Chris Bowen (Shadow Treasurer) sit either side of Tony
Jones. The two of them managed to degenerate into petty arguments a
number of times, which is business as usual between the two majors on
the show. Furthermore, the two nearly managed to speak as much as
Alan Jones, which is quite an achievement in itself. Normally, when
someone not so happy to talk until the cows come home is on, the two
pollies will be the ones with the most airtime. Neither of these
things are healthy for political discourse.
By placing them on either side of Jones and allowing them to snipe at
each other, they become the centre of our attention, and our
attention is being drawn to whatever political point they want to
score. How can we have good political discourse when the dominant
parties' idea of discourse is stale one-liners and repeated talking
points? All that the viewer sees is that a) these are our only
choices for government and b) our choices aren't very good. What is
even more problematic is that these tired talking points are
inevitably the things that get the most airtime. On a typical five
person panel, there will be these two politicians, an expert of some
kind, an artist/comedian/writer type, and a wild card (could be a
journo, another expert, another politician, another artiste, anything
really). The other three may all have something interesting to say,
or only some of them, but often they only get one or two chances to
properly answer a question. The two politicians will almost always
take up the most time, and the result is a diluted discussion.
There is another problem. I said earlier that it was specifically the
prominent members of major parties who like Q&A at the
moment. The reason for this is that the show is all about
individuals. Individuals are asked questions, individuals answer the
questions. How they answer the questions, and not necessarily what
they actually say, will determine how people think about them. The
more important the individual, the more weight is put to their
answer, and the more focus is paid to their answer after the show is
over. Again, this is not necessarily a bad thing. In fact, the more
members of parliament the public is aware of, the better. However,
when you're trying to engage in important political discussion, is a
televised forum the best place to do it? Does the policy remain as
the focus? You may have heard of the classic debate between John F.
Kennedy and Richard Nixon, where those listening on radio believed
Nixon won, but those watching on television believed Kennedy
performed better. The latter was, quite literally, about style over
substance, and that is what the medium of television is built for. If
you can combine the two, great, but time and time again we see
politicians picking style first. A pithy soundbite for the evening
news will be more effective at grabbing attention, after all.
So when you bring two politicians from parties vying for government
and put them in front of a television camera, and you tell them to
speak freely, do you really expect them to go into any great,
significant detail about their vision for the country? Because as it
stands now, you probably shouldn't. The style wins over the
substance, and such is the media cycle of today that the style has
actually become the substance.
But how can I say that Q&A sets the tone for political
discussion in this country, and that it turns the focus from the
parties and their policies towards the individuals and their image?
Well, let's look at a recent example. One of the people joining
Wilkinson on the panel on Monday was Malcolm Turnbull. Turnbull has
been at the centre of leadership speculation since the spill motion
was called against the Prime Minister recently. He was meant to
appear on the show as the Minister for Communications, which he did,
but for many in the media in the days since, his appearance was
really about presenting himself as 'alternative Prime Minister', a
nonsense title that is endemic of the focus of personality that the
media so loves.
For the next couple of days, his appearance on the programme was a major talking point for the media. David Crowe in The Australian claimed that his performance offered an alternative to Abbott's leadership. Mark Kenny for Fairfax proclaimed that the fight between potential Prime Ministers was the most interesting part of federal politics. Catherine McGrath from SBS called Turnbull a flirt. Most importantly, News Ltd proclaimed his performance as being 'Prime Ministerial', which is basically meant to be our version of 'Presidential' (even though the PM is not like a President). Here we see how easily Q&A set the tone for discussion in federal politics for the rest of the week. And what of this is not about image? What of this is not focussed on the individual?
What of this does not, little by little, weaken our political system every time it happens?
So, how do you fix these problems? Well, I have a few ideas, but I'm
sure there are more. I'm also sure the ABC isn't that interested in
them, but no matter. First, don't have a pollie from each major party
on every week. When you do have one on, you don't have to have one
from the other on for the sake of 'balance'. Make Jones, or whoever
is moderating, clamp down on the soundbites that they so love. If you
have two on (which will be fine occasionally), make them sit next to
each other. Put them on one end of the desk. They're not going to be
as likely to have a go at each other if they are physically next to
one another, and they won't be the centre of attention if they're way
down one end.
Television's place as a visual platform means that it is difficult to change the focus back to being about policy instead of image. This means that it is up to the media to stop focusing so much on what does and doesn't look good, and to instead hone in on the substance. Ultimately, Q&A can't change too much. Not because it's so
great that it shouldn't be changed, but rather that it's a difficult
format to change. These little changes would be positive, but you're
not going to suddenly improve the quality of discussion tenfold. The
show simply isn't designed for anything too high level. It's a fine
balancing act between levels of acceptable style and substance, and
I'm sure the ABC will have many more years to tweak it.
Well, as long as the government doesn't privatise it.
Sunday, 22 February 2015
Chris Bowen's 'gotcha' moment
If you have been paying any attention to Australian politics over the past few days, you will know that Chris Bowen, the Shadow Treasurer, got 'caught out' by Alan Jones on Sky News. Jones asked Bowen what the tax-free threshold was, Bowen didn't know and tried to dance around the fact that he couldn't remember.
Jones knew the answer ($18,200) and was more than happy to crow about it. But as Bowen pointed out, he wasn't on the show to do a 'pop quiz'.
Unfortunately for Bowen, the media seems to think that was exactly what he was on there for.
Every news outlet you can think of ran a leading story on his 'gaffe'. The Australian, Fairfax, ABC, Ninemsn, Yahoo!7 and SBS all ran a story. Piers Akerman felt it necessary to tell us that it was a 'huge dent in his credibility'.
So should we care?
No, no we should not.
While it would be nice for a potential Treasurer to remember the tax-free threshold on demand at all times, his inability to do so when it was not the topic he was planning to discuss does not reflect on his ability to be a Treasurer. A Treasurer should be able to envisage a good path for the economy in the short, medium and long term. Bowen's forgetfulness of a number does not mean he is incapable of pursuing a fiscal goal over six years.
Furthermore, Bowen doesn't really need to know this. Not only is it not particularly relevant to a Treasurer's broad fiscal plans, he also will have people remind him of it should he become Treasurer. The people in the Department of the Treasury will know these things, because it is their job to know. So, should he forget again, and should it actually become important for him to know (unlikely as it is), it still won't really matter that he didn't know on a television show in 2015.
So why did his slip-up feature in various parts of the media for days? Well, presumably the media thinks it is more important than it is. Or they think that the public will genuinely perceive it as a sign that Bowen is unfit for the role of Treasurer. It's an absurd notion, but in today's world of instant media and ever-shortening attention spans, it's one that will keep getting pushed.
Bowen was on Sky for a discussion on superannuation. No-one cares about that now, because there was a 'gaffe' to focus on instead of boring discussion that may have been important.
This pattern will keep repeating, and we are poorer for it.
Jones knew the answer ($18,200) and was more than happy to crow about it. But as Bowen pointed out, he wasn't on the show to do a 'pop quiz'.
Unfortunately for Bowen, the media seems to think that was exactly what he was on there for.
Every news outlet you can think of ran a leading story on his 'gaffe'. The Australian, Fairfax, ABC, Ninemsn, Yahoo!7 and SBS all ran a story. Piers Akerman felt it necessary to tell us that it was a 'huge dent in his credibility'.
So should we care?
No, no we should not.
While it would be nice for a potential Treasurer to remember the tax-free threshold on demand at all times, his inability to do so when it was not the topic he was planning to discuss does not reflect on his ability to be a Treasurer. A Treasurer should be able to envisage a good path for the economy in the short, medium and long term. Bowen's forgetfulness of a number does not mean he is incapable of pursuing a fiscal goal over six years.
Furthermore, Bowen doesn't really need to know this. Not only is it not particularly relevant to a Treasurer's broad fiscal plans, he also will have people remind him of it should he become Treasurer. The people in the Department of the Treasury will know these things, because it is their job to know. So, should he forget again, and should it actually become important for him to know (unlikely as it is), it still won't really matter that he didn't know on a television show in 2015.
So why did his slip-up feature in various parts of the media for days? Well, presumably the media thinks it is more important than it is. Or they think that the public will genuinely perceive it as a sign that Bowen is unfit for the role of Treasurer. It's an absurd notion, but in today's world of instant media and ever-shortening attention spans, it's one that will keep getting pushed.
Bowen was on Sky for a discussion on superannuation. No-one cares about that now, because there was a 'gaffe' to focus on instead of boring discussion that may have been important.
This pattern will keep repeating, and we are poorer for it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

